Investing in a fence is a big decision. Some fence types are built to be strong and last long, while others need to be replaced every few years. When it comes to aluminum and iron fences specifically, both are great choices but one is certainly better than the other. Fence installation is typically a costly endeavor, which is why knowing which fence type is best both aesthetically and financially is a must. If you’re unsure of which fence type to go with, check out this compare and contrast of aluminum and iron fencing.
Aluminum Fencing
Source: Tennessee Valley Fence
Of the two options, aluminum fencing is the most popular choice for most homeowners. Part of the appeal of aluminum fencing is that it has the look of iron fencing but with many more advantages. For one, aluminum fencing requires much less maintenance than iron and most other fence types. Due to the multiple protective coats aluminum fencing receives (as well as a powder paint coating), it doesn’t need to be repainted or refinished every few years, saving you money on both paint and labor. Speaking of money, on average aluminum fencing costs much, much less than traditional wrought iron because it is manufactured through mass production. This means it’s easier to make than iron fencing and easier to distribute. In addition, aluminum doesn’t rust like iron because it is a ferric metal. In fact, it’s been estimated that it would take over 500 years for aluminum to disintegrate! Aluminum fencing is also incredibly durable, making it harder to breach and more effective at keeping things out and your loved ones protected. It can be adjusted to fit your landscape, meaning you can install it on flat or sloped surfaces without any issue. Of course, even with its many benefits, aluminum fencing does come with some drawbacks as well.
Though it costs less than iron, aluminum fencing will cost more than wood fencing up front. Again, due to its low maintenance, it will cost less over time. In addition, aluminum fencing is not great for privacy. Aluminum fences are also rather see-through, thwarting any plans you may have for blocking out neighbors and prying eyes.
Iron Fencing
Source: Dallas Iron Fence
Though not as popular amongst home and business owners anymore, iron fencing still has its advantages. While it is a more expensive option that requires professional installation, iron fencing is incredibly aesthetically pleasing. Often chosen for its gothic elegance, iron fencing showcases beautiful curves, twists, spires, and more. Iron fences are also great for security. They can keep out burglars and trespassers thanks to their classic pointed spear tops as well as their smooth and hard to climb posts. Iron fences are also immune to the rotting, warping, and insect damage you would find on wooden fences, meaning you’ll have an easier time maintaining these fences.
Unfortunately, while iron fences have few disadvantages, the ones that they do have are pretty big:
- Price
- Weather Resistance
As already mentioned, iron fences are extremely expensive. The material itself is perhaps the most expensive of all used fencing materials, and the labor costs can bump the price up even more. In addition, if you want custom designs on your iron fence as well, this will increase the price even further. Weather resistance is another issue. While iron fencing is immune to rot, warping, and insect damage, it is not immune to rust. Excessive weather exposure can lead to serious rusting, ruining its look and even its integrity over time.
Which Fencing Type is Best?
When compared side by side, it’s clear that aluminum fencing is a great alternative to iron fencing. For homeowners on a budget with a busy lifestyle, the low maintenance and low cost of aluminum fencing makes this a prime option. Of course, iron fencing can still be the right choice for certain homeowners who have a bit more to spend. Overall, aluminum fencing offers a great alternative due to its aesthetic beauty, durability, low maintenance, and even lower cost.